South Africa’s Racism Row Deepens as Leaders Face Hate Speech Complaints

Heated words reignite old wounds

South Africa is once again grappling with a wave of ugly racial rhetoric, as high-profile political figures and public personalities face a string of hate speech complaints. What began as outrage over a podcast’s derogatory remarks about the coloured community has now spiralled into a multi-front political storm, reviving uncomfortable questions about whether the country has ever truly healed from its apartheid scars.

The Human Rights Commission (HRC) has confirmed it will investigate the Open Chats podcast after its hosts apologised for calling the coloured community “crazy”, an apology the Commission deemed insufficient.

Ministers in the spotlight

ActionSA MP Alan Beesley has lodged a complaint with the HRC against Minister of Sport, Arts and Culture Gayton McKenzie, accusing him of repeatedly using derogatory terms about black South Africans on social media. Beesley also filed a complaint against Public Works Minister Dean Macpherson for calling ActionSA supporters amaphara (petty thieves addicted to heroin) and “hobos.”

“Racism has no place in South Africa, regardless of who it targets,” Beesley said, adding that ActionSA is ready to take the matter to the Equality Court if necessary.

Mbalula’s comments spark outrage

ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula also faces backlash after AfriForum condemned what it called a “racist outburst” against white South Africans and Afrikaner refugees in the US. Mbalula allegedly labelled these refugees as car guards and murderers, prompting AfriForum to accuse him of blatant stereotyping.

Political analyst Piet Croucamp, however, noted the irony of AfriForum’s outrage, calling the organisation “race-obsessed” and arguing that its reaction only entrenches division.

The deeper problem

Experts say this is more than a string of isolated incidents, it’s a symptom of a society still struggling to reconcile with its past. Political analyst Rene Oosthuizen warned that the inflammatory rhetoric risks deepening social divides.

“We need responsible leadership and dialogue that builds understanding across racial and cultural lines,” Oosthuizen said.

Benjamin Rapanyane, a senior political lecturer at North-West University, agreed, adding: “South Africa has not healed from racism. We are still in a deep crisis when it comes to addressing this issue. Perhaps the National Dialogue can help us heal the deeper wounds.”

Social media reaction

On social media, the debate has been fierce. Some users are calling for stronger enforcement of hate speech laws, while others accuse the HRC of selective action. Hashtags like #EndRacismSA and #HRCInvestigate have been trending, with people sharing personal experiences of racism to underline that the problem is far from over.

More than politics

This controversy is not just about politicians exchanging insults, it’s about the soul of a nation that promised “Never Again” in 1994. Every new racial outburst chips away at the trust South Africans have tried to build for three decades.

If the country cannot find a way to hold all leaders accountable for their words, regardless of race or political affiliation, the vision of a united South Africa risks becoming just another empty slogan.

{Source: The Citizen}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com