Inside the Emotional Day Zurenah Smit Broke Down in Court

What was meant to be another step forward in the long-running murder trial of accused husband killer Zurenah Smit came to an abrupt halt on Wednesday – not because of legal objections or evidence disputes, but because the accused simply couldn’t continue speaking. One moment she was answering questions, the next she was sobbing uncontrollably in the witness stand, gasping that she “can’t breathe.”

It was one of those courtroom moments that hushes even the tapping of journalists’ keyboards.

A Morning of Testimony Turns Heavy

Zurenah, dressed modestly and flanked by her defence attorney Susan Kuun, was walking the court through what she remembered of the night her husband, 62-year-old Stellenbosch farmer Stefan Smit, was killed in 2019 at their Louisenhof Farm home.

Her story painted a chaotic, terrifying scene.

She told the court that she and Stefan were having dinner with a friend when they heard “a huge noise.” What followed, in her words, were flashes more than memories a dark figure, shouting about money, screaming, fear, and later nightmares of being strangled and lifted off her feet.

As her voice failed her, a court translator stepped in. But even that wasn’t enough to hold her steady. Tears overtook her, shoulders shaking as she recounted being thrown to the floor. Judge Wille had no choice but to pause the proceedings. Moments later, Zurenah was heard crying, repeating that she couldn’t breathe.

Court orderlies stood frozen before finally ushering her out gently.

State Pushes for Momentum as Emotions Slow the Trial

The case has dragged for years, and on Wednesday the State made it clear that they don’t want emotional breakdowns to derail progress any further.

State Prosecutor Renee Uys, visibly frustrated with delays, warned that at the current pace “this matter could move at a snail’s pace.” She asked the court to consider two drastic steps:

1. Revoke Zurenah’s bail and have her moved, or

2. Bring paramedics to court daily so proceedings won’t stall should she fall ill again.

Judge Wille approved the second option. Yes, medical personnel will now be on standby during testimony.

That alone shows just how intense this case has become.

Why This Trial Has Captivated the Public

This isn’t just another murder case. It’s a wealthy farm, inheritance tension, claims of drugging, robbed safes, and accusations of a staged robbery. It has the drama of a true-crime documentary and South Africans have been watching closely.

Zurenah and her co-accused Derek Sait are charged with killing Stefan and arranging the scene to look like a break-in gone wrong. The court previously heard that Zurenah and a guest were unharmed during the alleged attack a detail many observers still find suspicious.

Online comments echo the divided national mood:

“If she’s innocent, may the truth clear her name. If not justice for Stefan.”
“The crying could be trauma…or strategy. Courts must focus on facts.”

It’s a community split between sympathy and scepticism. After all, Zurenah reportedly wasn’t included in Stefan’s updated 2018 will a decision made after more than R200,000 in cash, Kruger Rand coins, and a firearm vanished from his safe. That, prosecutors say, was when motive entered the picture.

Zurenah denies every accusation, including claims she tried to hire people to kill her husband or drugged him using sleeping tablets.

Medical Notes, Nerves and a Long Road Ahead

Before testimony resumed earlier in the week, the court received a medical referral letter confirming she had visited Lady Michaelis Clinic after a 3-day hospital observation. The letter acknowledged ongoing symptoms, but confirmed she was fit to testify.

Whether emotionally ready is another question.

The trial is set to continue on Thursday morning at 10am, with paramedics at the door, just in case.

More than a Trial, A Human Story Unfolding in Real Time

Whatever the verdict one day becomes, this moment will linger:

A woman crying in a silent courtroom.
A state demanding pace.
A family waiting for answers.
And a country watching closely.

Because beneath the legal jargon and criminal charges lies a simple truth, someone died, someone is on trial, and the line between victim and villain is still up to the court to decide.

{Source: IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com