Best of Johannesburg
Can You Sue the Government for a Pothole Accident in South Africa?

When the road gives way: your rights after a pothole accident
You’re cruising through Johannesburg or any South African road, and suddenly your car hits a massive pothole. Your vehicle lurches, maybe you suffer damage or injury, and you wonder: Can I hold the government responsible? The short answer: yes, under the right circumstances, the road authority can be held liable for pothole damage or injury. But it’s not guaranteed and depends on whether the authority met its duty to maintain the road.
Who to hold accountable? Road type matters
The first step is working out which agency was responsible for the stretch of road where the accident happened:
-
If it were on a national route (e.g., N1, N3), the national road agency is likely liable.
-
On a provincial route, the relevant Department of Public Works or Roads is involved.
-
If it were a municipal street in Johannesburg, the local city or municipality would be responsible.
Get this wrong and your claim will stall before it even begins.
The legal ingredients: duty, breach and causation
For a successful claim, you must show three core elements:
-
Duty of care: The road authority had a legal duty to keep the road safe for motorists.
-
Breach (negligence): They either knew (or reasonably should have known) about the pothole and failed to repair it or warn drivers in time.
-
Causation and harm: The pothole directly caused your damage or injury, and you can quantify that harm (repairs, medical bills, etc.).
Courts in 2025 are increasingly holding authorities accountable when all three are proven.
Getting your evidence in order quickly
You’ll want to collect everything as soon as possible:
-
Clear photos or videos of the pothole and your vehicle damage, recording the precise location, time, and conditions.
-
Repair quotes or invoices, and any medical records if you were injured.
-
Police or accident reports, plus affidavits or witness statements if available.
-
Records or proof that the pothole had been reported previously (this shows the authority had knowledge).
The strength of your case often boils down to how well you documented everything.
Time is ticking; mind the deadlines
You must act promptly. Some of the key timelines to keep in mind:
-
For vehicle damage claims, you usually serve a notice of intention to the relevant authority within about six months of the incident.
-
For personal injury claims in South Africa, you may have up to three years to claim, but this depends on the road authority and the circumstances.
If you miss the deadline, you could lose the right to claim altogether.
Real cases: the courts are starting to issue judgments
Recent South African rulings confirm this isn’t just theory:
-
In the Free State, a court found the roads department 100% liable for a serious accident caused by a large pothole on the R34.
-
In Gauteng, the provincial roads department has faced hundreds of pothole-related claims in recent years, costing millions in legal fees and settlements.
These outcomes show that authorities are vulnerable if they don’t act when they should.
Vehicle damage vs personal injury: know the difference
There are two fairly distinct tracks:
-
Vehicle damage only: You claim against the road authority for repairs, recovery of costs, etc.
-
Personal injury: If you were hurt, you may claim through the road authority, but if another driver was involved, you may also claim via the Road Accident Fund (RAF). Each route has its own processes and deadlines.
Make sure you’re clear which path applies to your situation.
What to do next if you’re affected
-
Stop, photograph, and record everything safe to do so.
-
Report the damage/accident to the police and the relevant authority.
-
Collect all documentation: vehicle or medical treatment records, repair quotes, photos, witness details, and prior road-fault reports.
-
Serve the correct notice within the allowed timeframe.
-
Seek legal advice from someone experienced in state liability or delict claims to guide you through the process.
-
Don’t delay; turning a case around quickly increases your chance of success.
Why this matters in Johannesburg and beyond
In Gauteng and particularly Johannesburg, the pothole problem is more than annoying; it’s expensive and dangerous. Every time motorists dodge craters and risk damage or injury, it highlights a broken cycle: taxpayers pay for legal payouts instead of road repairs. By standing up for your rights, you help shift the burden back to the authorities and push for better roads.
When you next hear a thud, feel the jolt, or realise your wheel has sunk into a crater, ask yourself: Who will pay for this? In 2025, in South Africa, the evidence shows the answer might finally be the road authority, provided you’re prepared.
Also read: No Warning, No Power? The Truth About Power Disconnections
Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter, TikT
For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com
Featured Image: KH Plant