Thabo Bester’s Legal Team Fights To Block Netflix Documentary Over Fair Trial Concerns

A Legal Battle Over The Screen

The saga of convicted murderer and rapist Thabo Bester has taken yet another dramatic turn. This time, the drama is playing out not in headlines or prison cells, but in the North Gauteng High Court. Bester’s lawyer, Advocate Moafrika Wa Maila, is pushing to stop Netflix from releasing its much-hyped documentary Beauty and the Bester.

According to Wa Maila, allowing the documentary to stream while court proceedings are still ongoing would be “prejudicial” to Bester. The argument centres on one of the most fundamental principles of justice: the right to a fair trial.

What The Court Heard

Wa Maila pointed to scenes in the trailer, where public figures and even family members of co-accused Dr Nandipha Magudumana appear to pass judgment. Former Constitutional Court Justice Edwin Cameron is quoted in the trailer, saying: “As a judge, I have never seen such a thing,” referring to Bester’s dramatic 2022 prison escape.

For the defence, this creates a problem. If the public is already consuming a version of events packaged for entertainment, it could cement a narrative that prejudices both Bester and Magudumana before the trial is concluded. “This goes against his right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty,” Wa Maila told the court.

Public Fascination With The Case

The Bester-Magudumana saga has gripped South Africans like few other true-crime stories. From the infamous Mangaung prison escape to the couple’s arrest in Tanzania, the case has sparked debates about corruption, gender dynamics, and the media’s role in shaping public opinion.

On social media, reaction to the Netflix trailer has been swift and polarised. Some viewers are eager for a polished deep dive into the story, comparing it to global hits like Making a Murderer. Others warn that releasing such a documentary now risks turning a live criminal matter into sensationalist entertainment.

Justice Versus Public Interest

South Africa has long wrestled with how to balance free expression and the right to a fair trial. This case is now forcing the courts to confront that tension head-on. Should Netflix be allowed to release the documentary in the name of public interest and freedom of information? Or should the rights of the accused take precedence until the dust of the trial settles?

A Story Still Being Written

For now, the spotlight shifts from the streaming platform back to the courtroom. Whether or not Beauty and the Bester premieres on schedule, the case is a reminder that the pursuit of justice in South Africa is not only fought in legal chambers but also in the court of public opinion.

Source: SABC News 

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com