A step closer to freedom, a step deeper into anguish

The news that Donovan Moodley, convicted of the horrific murder of Bond University student Leigh Matthews, has been approved for parole has reignited a storm of emotions for her parents, Rob and Sharon Matthews. Moodley, who has spent over two decades behind bars, now faces the possibility of releasethough the final decision rests with the Minister of Correctional Services.

Tania Koen, the attorney representing the Matthews family, described the moment as “emotionally draining,” noting that the couple did not feel capable of attending the parole hearing. “This is the third time the board has considered parole,” Koen said, underscoring the ongoing trauma the family endures.

The parole process: far from simple

Moodley’s path to potential freedom is far from guaranteed. South Africa’s parole system for life sentences involves multiple layers of scrutiny: the Case Management Committee reviews the case first, followed by the Correctional Supervision and Parole Board, and finally, the National Council for Correctional Services before a ministerial decision is made.

Despite the board’s approval, Koen stressed that the Matthews family is still evaluating their options. The board’s recommendation does not automatically translate to Moodley walking free, leaving the family in a state of limbo.

Victims’ rights and unanswered questions

A major source of concern for the Matthews family is the lack of access to Moodley’s latest rehabilitation profile, which includes expert evaluations on his progress behind bars. Koen emphasised: “We applied to be given access because victims need to know whether he has truly rehabilitated. But he denied us this right.”

Available information is limited to the last 18 months, after Moodley’s transfer to Leeukop Prison in Johannesburg. The absence of detailed insights into his rehabilitation fuels anxiety about whether he is ready to reintegrate safely into society.

Two years ago, Moodley challenged the parole board’s prior denials, invoking “ubuntu,” an African philosophy of mutual respect and community responsibility. While the courts granted him a new hearing, he was once again denied paroleuntil now.

Revisiting a tragic past

Moodley was sentenced on August 4, 2005, to life imprisonment for the 2004 murder of 21-year-old Leigh Matthews. The case horrified South Africa: Moodley had kidnapped Leigh, extorted R50,000 from her parents, and ultimately shot her four times, leaving her body in the veld. He also received additional sentences of 15 years for kidnapping and 10 years for extortion.

During his incarceration, Moodley completed an LLB degree, a detail that has not quelled public debate about whether he has genuinely reformed. Social media has been awash with discussions, ranging from calls for the minister to uphold the board’s decision to appeals for victims’ rights to remain central in parole considerations.

An emotional crossroads

For Rob and Sharon Matthews, Moodley’s parole approval is less about legal process and more about emotional survival. “Just as he exercises his rights, the victims deserve the same consideration,” Koen said, highlighting the tension between rehabilitation and the need for justice and closure.

As the nation watches, the final decision by the Minister of Correctional Services will determine whether a convicted murderer begins a new chapter in freedom or remains behind barsa decision fraught with legal, moral, and emotional weight.

{Source: IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com