Gareth Cliff’s Take On Charlie Kirk’s Death Splits South Africans Online

Controversial broadcaster Gareth Cliff has found himself at the centre of yet another heated online storm after weighing in on the killing of US activist Charlie Kirk.

Kirk, who was 31, was shot dead on September 10 while delivering a speech at Utah Valley University. His death sent shockwaves across the globe, particularly among those who admired his uncompromising defence of free speech and conservative values.

Gareth Cliff Steps In

Cliff dedicated an episode of his YouTube show Truth Report to Kirk, praising his influence on debates around free speech and his ability to rally young people. He also took to X (formerly Twitter) to call the assassination “extremely sad” and one with “massive political ramifications.”

Reposting J.K. Rowling’s thoughts on the dangers of punishing opposing views with violence, Cliff framed Kirk’s death as evidence of a deeper ideological clash between free speech advocates and what he described as “leftist ideologies.”

Social Media Firestorm

Unsurprisingly, Cliff’s remarks ignited fierce online debate. Some praised him for defending free expression, while others accused him of glorifying a man they viewed as divisive.

• @Naomi_Wonders: “Free speech terrifies them because it exposes their lies. Now a man is dead for daring to speak.”

• @Petro_Squell: “The saying ‘you live by a gun, you die by a gun’. Good riddance to a racist.”

• @sobantuntlokwan: “Even hardcore racists deserve a better way to depart this world.”

• @Unnamingmyself: “Charlie Kirk profited from division and violence. The irony is that gun violence claimed his life.”

The split reflects broader tensions in South Africa too, where Cliff himself has a history of polarising audiences with his unapologetic commentary on politics, race, and culture.

Why This Story Resonates In South Africa

South Africans are no strangers to polarised debates about speech, identity, and politics. Cliff’s comments struck a nerve because they mirror our own struggles with balancing freedom of expression and the harm caused by inflammatory rhetoric.

For some, Kirk’s death is a chilling reminder of the violence that can erupt when politics turns toxic. For others, it exposes the hypocrisy of leaders who demand free speech while using it to marginalise or provoke.

A Story That Won’t Fade Soon

With the FBI confirming the arrest of Tyler Robinson in connection with the shooting, but noting his lack of cooperation, questions still hang heavy over Kirk’s assassination. Meanwhile, Cliff’s reaction has ensured the debate has reached South African shores, where opinions remain as divided as ever.

What’s clear is that the conversation around free speech, accountability, and violence is not just an American issue it’s one that resonates deeply in South Africa too.

Source:IOL 

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com