Why Israel Wants To Keep International Journalists Out Of Gaza

Israel Defends Media Ban As Court Deadline Arrives

Israel’s government has formally asked the Supreme Court to uphold its ban on international journalists entering Gaza independently, arguing that the territory remains too dangerous despite an ongoing ceasefire.

In a late-night submission filed ahead of a court deadline, officials said allowing unescorted foreign media into Gaza would pose unacceptable security risks. The filing marks the clearest signal yet that Israel has no intention of reopening Gaza to independent international reporting in the near future.

Since the war began in October 2023, following the Hamas-led attack on Israel, foreign journalists have been blocked from entering Gaza unless embedded with the Israeli military. That restriction has remained in place for over a year, even as global scrutiny of the war’s human cost has intensified.

A Long-Running Legal Challenge From Journalists

The challenge to the ban was brought by the Foreign Press Association, which represents hundreds of international reporters working in Israel and the Palestinian territories. The group petitioned the court in 2024, calling for immediate and unrestricted access to Gaza so journalists could report independently from the ground.

Judges repeatedly granted the government extensions to explain its position, before setting an early January deadline for a final response. That response, now on record, makes it clear the government believes the risks outweigh press freedom concerns.

According to the submission, defence officials maintain that journalists entering Gaza without military escort could be exposed to serious danger, especially given ongoing military operations and intelligence-sensitive activity.

Ceasefire On Paper, Violence On The Ground

While a ceasefire came into effect in October, Israeli officials argue the situation remains volatile. Gaza’s health ministry says more than 420 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces since the truce began, while Israel reports the deaths of three soldiers during the same period.

Defence Minister Israel Katz has warned that rapid military responses to alleged Hamas violations could put journalists in harm’s way. Those concerns were echoed in the court submission, which stressed that conditions on the ground can change without warning.

Hostage Search Adds Another Layer Of Tension

The government also pointed to the ongoing search for the remains of the last Israeli hostage believed to be held in Gaza. The body of Ran Gvili, killed during the October 7, 2023 attack, has not yet been recovered.

Officials suggested that opening Gaza to international media at this stage could interfere with sensitive operations linked to that search. All other hostages taken during the attack have since been returned to Israel, both living and deceased.

Press Freedom Versus Security

For media freedom advocates, the continued ban has become one of the most controversial aspects of the war. International organisations and journalists have repeatedly argued that relying solely on military-embedded reporting limits transparency and prevents independent verification of events inside Gaza.

On social media, journalists and press rights groups have reacted with frustration, warning that prolonged restrictions risk setting a dangerous precedent for conflict reporting worldwide. Supporters of the ban, however, argue that no story is worth a journalist’s life, especially in an active war zone.

What Happens Next

The Gaza Strip remains effectively sealed off to the world’s media, with coverage largely dependent on local journalists and military-approved access. The Supreme Court is expected to rule on the matter, though no date has been announced.

Until then, the standoff between security concerns and the right to report freely continues, with Gaza still largely unseen through independent international eyes.

{Source:IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com