Supreme Court Revives Nulane Corruption Trial

A pivotal ruling reignites South Africa’s state capture reckoning

After months of legal uncertainty, one of South Africa’s most significant state capture-related corruption cases is back on the table. The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) has ruled in favour of the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), breathing new life into the Nulane Investments corruption case, and offering a moment of vindication for the country’s battered justice system.

Turning back the clock on a controversial discharge

Last year, many were stunned when Acting Judge Gusha dismissed charges against several accused in the Nulane case, citing insufficient evidence under Section 174 of the Criminal Procedure Act. It felt like yet another letdown in the long and painful journey to hold the architects of state capture accountable.

But now, in a move that’s being seen as a judicial course correction, the SCA has overturned that decision — ordering that the accused can be retried before a different judge.

Who’s on trial and why it matters

At the heart of the case are individuals and entities tied to one of the more intricate financial webs of the state capture era. Key figures include:

• Iqbal Sharma, former government official and businessman

• Nulane Investment, Sharma’s company

• Peter Thabethe, former head of the Free State Department of Agriculture

• Seipati Dhlamini and Limakatso Moorosi, former senior officials in the same department

• Ronica Ragavan, acting for Islandsite Investment, a Gupta-linked firm

• Dinesh Patel, Sharma’s brother-in-law

The case centers on allegations of procurement fraud and irregular contracts awarded during a period when the Free State government was deeply entangled with private interests.

It’s a trial that isn’t just about individual wrongdoing — it’s symbolic of the wider rot that seeped into the state under the shadow of the Gupta family’s influence.

What the Supreme Court’s ruling signals

The Investigating Directorate Against Corruption (IDAC), which led the case, argued that Judge Gusha misapplied the law and unfairly dismissed their efforts. The SCA has now affirmed that there’s a legitimate case to answer, giving prosecutors the green light to try again.

To some legal observers, the ruling is about more than this one case — it’s about reasserting the integrity of the justice process and restoring public confidence in a system that many have written off as toothless in the face of elite corruption.

Progress beyond the courtroom

While this ruling is a major win for the NPA, it’s not the only sign of forward movement. Since IDAC became a permanent unit in August 2024, it’s been steadily building momentum:

• 133 active investigations underway

• 50 cases already enrolled in court

• R14.3 billion in frozen assets, in partnership with the Asset Forfeiture Unit

• R8.2 billion channelled into the Criminal Asset Recovery Account (CARA)

There’s also a new emphasis on digital forensics extracting and analysing encrypted data from devices previously out of reach. This could be a game-changer in prosecuting high-level corruption, where paper trails are often replaced with digital footprints.

South Africans still waiting for justice

For many citizens, especially those who’ve watched years of commission testimony go unpunished, the frustration runs deep. Social media has reflected a mix of relief and scepticism.

One user on X posted, “Good ruling, but when are we going to see someone actually serve time?” Another wrote, “Let’s hope this isn’t another rerun of delay tactics and technicalities.”

The public appetite for justice is real and patience is wearing thin.

A long road, but movement nonetheless

The Nulane case has always been more than just a trial. It’s a test of whether South Africa’s institutions can rise from the ashes of state capture and hold powerful people accountable.

The SCA’s decision gives the NPA another chance to do just that. And in a country still rebuilding trust in its democratic institutions, that chance couldn’t come at a more critical time.

{Source: IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com