When Home Is No Longer Safe: How Parents Became Perpetrators in South Africa’s Most Shocking Child Abuse Cases

The Place Meant to Be Safest

For most children, home is meant to be a refuge, a place of comfort, protection and unconditional care. Parents are expected to be shields against a harsh world. But 2025 shattered that assumption for many South Africans, as case after case revealed a disturbing truth: some of the gravest dangers to children are coming from inside their own homes.

The year has forced the country to confront an uncomfortable reality, that parental violence, neglect, exploitation and even murder are not rare exceptions, but part of a wider, deeply rooted crisis.

Cases That Shook the Nation

Few stories have haunted South Africa like that of six-year-old Joshlin Smith. Her disappearance in February sent communities into panic and parents into fear. Months later, the truth was devastating.

In May, the Western Cape High Court sentenced Joshlin’s mother, Kelly Smith, along with Jacquen Appollis and Steveno van Rhyn, to life imprisonment for kidnapping and trafficking. The court heard that Joshlin had been sold for R20,000, a detail that left many South Africans stunned and angry. Judge Nathan Erasmus noted the complete lack of remorse shown by the accused, while Justice Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi said no sentence could undo the damage caused.

The case became a painful symbol of how greed and betrayal can eclipse even the most basic parental instinct.

Murder Disguised as Care

Another case that horrified the country was that of two-year-old Kutlwano Shalaba. Police allege his mother, Keneilwe Shalaba, poisoned him in November 2024 and buried his body near the R28 in Bekkersdal with the help of a traditional healer, Sebokoana Khounyana.

The charges, premeditated murder and human trafficking are chilling on their own. Even more disturbing were allegations that the child was targeted because his mother did not want a son and had been presenting him as a girl. Both accused remain in custody as the case continues, leaving South Africans grappling with how such cruelty could occur under the guise of motherhood.

A Mother Accused

The death of 11-year-old Jayden-Lee Meek added another layer of heartbreak. Reported missing after school in May, his body was found the following day just metres from his home in Fleurhof.

When his mother, Tiffany Nicole Meek, was arrested two months later, public shock turned into disbelief. She now faces charges including murder, child abuse and defeating the ends of justice. For many, the case underscored a recurring theme: the person expected to raise the alarm was allegedly the one responsible.

“Children Are Not Safe at Home”

Child protection experts say these cases are not isolated tragedies. According to Dr Shaheda Omar of the Teddy Bear Foundation, decades of research and crime statistics show that children are most often harmed by people closest to them.

“The cases of Joshlin, Jayden-Lee and others sit on top of a much larger pattern,” she explains. “Biological parents, caregivers and relatives are frequently the perpetrators.”

Save the Children South Africa echoes this concern. CEO Gugu Xaba points to widespread household violence and illegal corporal punishment as signs of systemic failure, not individual moral collapse.

Why Is This Happening?

Experts say the roots of parental violence are complex. Poverty, inequality, substance abuse, mental health challenges, harmful gender norms and unresolved generational trauma all play a role. Weak child protection systems and delayed interventions often mean warning signs are missed until it’s too late.

Social media reactions to these cases reflect both outrage and fear. Many parents admit they no longer assume danger comes from strangers. Instead, they worry about what happens behind closed doors even in seemingly “normal” homes.

Beyond Arrests: What Must Change

While prosecutions are necessary, experts warn they are not enough. Ending violence against children requires long-term, coordinated action: stronger child protection services, better community reporting systems, mental health and substance abuse support, and economic interventions that reduce household stress.

Perhaps most importantly, it requires breaking the silence. Communities, schools, religious leaders and the media all play a role in making abuse visible and unacceptable.

Because until home becomes safe again, no child in South Africa truly is.

{Source: The Citizen}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com