SABC Suspends Presenter After Backlash Over Ramphele Gaza-Holocaust Remarks

SABC Pulls Presenter After Heated Gaza Interview

The South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) has removed news presenter Juliet Newell from the air following a controversial interview with anti-apartheid activist Dr Mamphela Ramphele. The interview, which compared the crisis in Gaza to the Holocaust, drew swift public and activist backlash, putting the broadcaster under scrutiny.

During the broadcast, Newell challenged Ramphele’s analogy, asking whether likening images of starving Palestinians to the Holocaust was provocative. Ramphele responded: “The Holocaust happened, and it continues in different forms. Do we wait for millions to die to call this what it is?”

Public Outcry and Media Criticism

The interview sparked criticism from the Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC) and media activists, who accused the SABC of echoing foreign narratives and downplaying the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. In an open letter, the PSC called the broadcaster’s language biased, highlighting phrases like “allegations of genocide” as misleading. They urged the SABC to report accurately, describing the events in Gaza as genocide rather than a conventional war.

Media activist Hassen Lorgat echoed these concerns, noting that the public broadcaster has a duty to provide unbiased reporting. “This approach sanitises mass atrocities and misleads South Africans,” he said.

SABC Responds

In a statement, the SABC said Newell was taken off air in line with internal protocols. The broadcaster emphasised its commitment to public trust and adherence to editorial policies, which it said aim to provide credible, accessible news content.

Experts have weighed in on the polarised debate. Professor Theo Neethling from the University of the Free State noted that the comparison to the Holocaust has divided opinion, with some insisting it reflects systematic oppression while others view it as historically inaccurate.

Context and Cultural Relevance

South Africa has a long history of solidarity with Palestine, rooted in its anti-apartheid struggle. Comparisons to the Holocaust evoke strong emotions, reflecting the country’s historical consciousness and commitment to human rights. The SABC controversy underscores the challenge of reporting on sensitive international issues while balancing public sentiment, editorial policy, and ethical journalism.

The incident has sparked conversations on social media, with users split between defending Ramphele’s statement as a moral imperative and criticizing the broadcaster for framing it controversially.

{Source: IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com