Mkhwanazi vs Mchunu: SAPS Feud Leaves a ‘Dented’ Badge

As tensions boil over between Police Commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi and Minister Senzo Mchunu, experts warn the fallout could shatter public trust in law enforcement.

Leadership clash threatens public trust

South Africans are no strangers to political tension, but when the fight spills into the upper ranks of law enforcement, it’s not just politics at stake. It’s trust.

That’s the growing concern after a very public dispute erupted between KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi and Minister of Police Senzo Mchunu. While the exact details of the feud remain murky, the damage to the South African Police Service (SAPS) is becoming painfully clear.

According to Tshepo Matseba, a reputation management expert, this kind of internal drama at the top of SAPS doesn’t just stay behind the boardroom doors, it seeps into communities, damaging the credibility of officers who risk their lives daily.

“Trust and integrity are fundamental to the effective operation of any public institution,” said Matseba. “Especially those entrusted with the safety of citizens.”

Not just a ‘leadership issue’, it’s systemic

Criminologist Willem Els of the Institute for Security Studies agrees. He warns that when senior figures publicly clash, it undermines the very idea of unbiased law enforcement, the belief that the police serve justice, not politics.

“This scandal has already tarnished the image of the police,” Els said. “It doesn’t matter if the allegations are proven or dismissed. Once the seed of doubt is planted, the moral authority of the institution is eroded.”

Els says that these kinds of disputes expose deeper issues around power dynamics, political interference, and internal accountability, which continue to haunt the SAPS, particularly in provinces like KwaZulu-Natal, where crime levels and corruption concerns run high.

Who pays the price? The officers on the ground

While the spotlight is firmly on Mkhwanazi and Mchunu, the real cost of the feud is being paid by ordinary SAPS members, the officers on the ground who are now facing a crisis of credibility in their communities.

“When leadership fails, it reflects on everyone in uniform,” said Matseba. “The vast majority of SAPS officers are committed and hardworking. But public scandals blur the lines between the guilty and the innocent.”

For many South Africans already grappling with issues like gender-based violence, police corruption, and slow investigations, this latest clash only adds fuel to the fire. In townships and rural areas, where trust in the justice system is already fragile, stories like these can break it entirely.

Political interference or institutional weakness?

The ANC has publicly called for “urgent action” on allegations of political interference in SAPS operations, a nod to the larger question: is this feud about ego, or something more systemic?

Several analysts have warned that until SAPS leadership is protected from political pressure, South Africa’s justice system will continue to be vulnerable to manipulation, selective policing, and low morale among officers.

A fragile moment for SAPS and for the country

With crime rates still high, police-community trust still recovering from Marikana, and SAPS still battling allegations of internal abuse and corruption, this leadership dispute could not come at a worse time.

And as both Mchunu and Mkhwanazi continue to dig in, experts say the only real path forward is one rooted in transparency, accountability, and decisive resolution, not more political manoeuvring.

Restore the badge before it breaks

South Africa needs a police service that is respected, trusted, and above all, independent. The Mkhwanazi-Mchunu fallout has reminded the public, once again, how quickly that trust can be lost when egos are prioritised over duty.

As one officer in Durban put it anonymously: “We wear the same badge, but when the top starts fighting, the public sees all of us as the problem.”

Until SAPS leadership begins leading by example, the battle for credibility will remain an uphill one.

{Source: The Citizen}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com