Why SARS’s New Rules Could Leave Taxpayers With Nowhere to Hide

For years, South Africans who made an honest slip on their tax returns could breathe a little easier. A small phrase tucked into the Tax Administration Act  “bona fide inadvertent error” meant SARS couldn’t always pounce on them with harsh penalties. That protection is now hanging by a thread.

The end of a safety net

The National Treasury’s 2025 Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill has effectively redrawn the lines. While the words in the law haven’t been deleted, Treasury’s “clarification” makes it clear: the error exemption only applies in very limited cases namely substantial understatements, which are calculated mechanically rather than judged by behaviour.

In plain English? If you make an innocent mistake this tax season, whether rushing through eFiling before the midnight deadline or battling the fine print with your tax practitioner SARS may no longer see it as a forgivable error. Instead, it could be slapped down as negligence, with penalties of up to 200% of the shortfall on what you owe.

A brewing storm between taxpayers and the state

Tax experts argue this isn’t really “clarification” at all, but a quiet closing of a loophole. Tax Consulting SA has already flagged the shift as dangerous for taxpayers, saying it tilts the system heavily in SARS’s favour.

Technically, the broader exemption still exists in the written law. But practically, anyone trying to claim it in court will face the Treasury’s memo, which SARS will lean on as its shield. Litigation may drag out for years, all while interest compounds, bank accounts risk being frozen, and debt collectors hover in the wings.

On social media, frustration is already bubbling. Many South Africans point out that errors often come from a lack of guidance or overly complex filing processes and that punishing “honest mistakes” is tone-deaf in a country where compliance is already fragile.

Filing season pressure

The timing couldn’t be worse. We’re in the middle of tax filing season, the very period where rushed submissions and miscalculations are most likely. For many taxpayers juggling side hustles, retrenchment packages, or business income, the risk of slipping up is real.

The change also places extra strain on tax practitioners, who now carry greater liability for getting every number right. A misplaced digit or an overlooked deduction could translate into crippling penalties for their clients.

What it means for taxpayers now

The practical takeaway? Assume SARS won’t forgive mistakes. That’s the hard reality. The old safety net is gone, and every filing must be approached with meticulous care. As Tax Consulting SA put it bluntly:

“File on time, file accurately the first time, and assume that every mistake, however honest, will be treated as understatement.”

A bigger question of trust

This move reflects a broader tension in South Africa’s tax system. On one hand, Treasury wants to plug loopholes and strengthen compliance. On the other, ordinary taxpayers feel squeezed, punished for errors while corruption and waste in state spending remain unaddressed.

In the end, SARS’s stricter stance may bring in more revenue, but at the cost of goodwill. And in a country where trust in institutions is already brittle, that may prove to be the biggest tax liability of all.

{Source: BusinessTech}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com