South Africa Placed On US Human Trafficking Watch List Amid Rising Tensions

South Africa has landed on the United States’ human trafficking watch list, a move that raises questions about the country’s international standing and the direction of its relationship with Washington.

The decision, announced in the US State Department’s latest Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report, placed both South Africa and Brazil on the so-called “Tier 2 Watch List.” This signals that while both nations are making some effort to tackle human trafficking, they are not doing enough and could face sanctions if they fail to improve.

What The Watch List Means

Countries on the Tier 2 Watch List are under pressure to show greater progress in fighting forced labour, sex trafficking, and other forms of modern slavery. If South Africa remains on this list for two consecutive years without improvement, it risks being downgraded to Tier 3, which carries significant consequences.

Tier 3 countries may be denied certain forms of US foreign assistance and face restrictions on participation in cultural and educational exchange programs. The US President can also instruct institutions such as the International Monetary Fund and World Bank to withhold loans, with exceptions made only for humanitarian or trade-related purposes.

Why South Africa Was Downgraded

According to the report, South Africa has made “significant efforts” in combating trafficking, including launching its first sub-provincial task team and convicting more traffickers. However, progress has been uneven. The government reportedly identified fewer victims, investigated fewer cases, and initiated fewer prosecutions compared to previous years.

Brazil was faulted for similar shortcomings, with declines in both investigations and prosecutions.

A Strained US-South Africa Relationship

The timing of the announcement has not gone unnoticed. Relations between Pretoria and Washington have been tense under President Donald Trump, who has accused South Africa of persecuting its white minority and even launched a controversial refugee programme for white South Africans. Earlier this year, the Trump administration cut humanitarian aid to South Africa on human rights grounds.

Adding to the friction, members of the US Congress have introduced bills to review the trade relationship between the two nations, with some proposals calling for direct sanctions against ANC officials and government leaders.

Social And Political Reactions

The news has sparked debate both locally and abroad. On South African social media, some users voiced frustration that the government’s shortcomings could open the door to sanctions at a time when the economy is already fragile. Others accused Washington of using the human trafficking report as political leverage in an increasingly hostile relationship.

In the US, reactions have been mixed. Republican officials have framed the move as a necessary step in upholding “American values,” while some Democratic lawmakers criticised the State Department for gutting the very office responsible for monitoring trafficking noting staff cuts of over 70% earlier this year.

A Global Human Rights Question

Human trafficking is one of the most pressing human rights issues of our time, and the US TIP Report is considered a global benchmark. But this year’s rollout was unusually delayed and stripped of the usual media briefings, raising further questions about the politicisation of a critical human rights tool.

For South Africa, the challenge now is not only to demonstrate tangible progress in fighting trafficking but also to navigate a complicated diplomatic landscape where human rights concerns overlap with political tensions.

{Source:Business Tech }

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com