High Court backs South Africa’s Venice Biennale participation despite legal challenge

South Africa is set to showcase its artistic talent at the Venice Biennale 2026, after the Gauteng High Court dismissed a legal challenge aimed at halting the country’s participation. The ruling ensures that the South African pavilion will proceed under a newly designed, industry-led selection process.

The court case, brought by artists Gabrielle Goliath, Ingrid Lehlohonolo Masondo, James Malcolm MacDonald, and the Campaign for Free Expression, sought to overturn a departmental decision to outsource the curation of the pavilion. The applicants argued that the new approach undermined transparency and artistic integrity.

From government-led to sector-driven

Traditionally, the Department of Sports, Arts and Culture managed the selection process for the South African pavilion at Venice, running an open call for submissions and convening an independent committee to shortlist artists.

However, in November 2025, the department announced a shift to a sector-driven model, outsourcing operational responsibilities to Art Periodic. The private organisation is tasked with managing the pavilion space at the Arsenale, securing production funding, contracting the exhibition, and ensuring it meets international standards.

“The new approach represents an evolution in governance, moving from a purely government-led process to a collaborative model with industry stakeholders,” the court judgment read.

Selection process under scrutiny

Under Art Periodic’s oversight, a working group of curators from five South African institutions was convened to solicit and evaluate artist proposals. Selection criteria included conceptual strength, artistic vision, feasibility, and alignment with the pavilion’s mission to strengthen South Africa’s international cultural presence.

The committee, composed of respected arts professionals, including academics, museum owners, and art journalists published an open call inviting curators to submit proposals responding to the curatorial vision for Venice 2026.

Submissions are expected to explore the vitality, nuance, and complexity of contemporary South African art, offering reflections on cultural ownership in a global context.

Court dismisses challenge

The High Court dismissed the legal action, ruling in favour of the department and Art Periodic, and ordered the applicants to pay costs. The judgment emphasised that the department continues to fund the official pavilion space and retains oversight, ensuring alignment with national protocols.

The court noted that the legal challenge did not demonstrate sufficient grounds to block the participation, and that the new approach was consistent with the department’s mandate to promote South African artists internationally.

Public and sector reactions

On social media, the ruling has been met with mixed responses. Some artists and cultural commentators expressed relief, noting that the Venice Biennale is a critical platform for South African art to gain international recognition. Others raised concerns about transparency in outsourcing curation, echoing the concerns of the applicants.

Arts journalist Xolani Msimang tweeted: “While outsourcing can bring expertise, it’s crucial that we safeguard fair access for all South African artists. The debate around Art Periodic shows how fragile trust can be in our art ecosystem.”

A new era for South African art abroad

The Venice Biennale, which runs from May to November 2026, remains one of the most prestigious global platforms for contemporary art. South Africa’s pavilion, located in the historic Arsenale complex, has historically been an opportunity to market local talent to international audiences and foster dialogue around the country’s artistic innovation.

With the High Court ruling in place, Art Periodic will move forward with finalising the curatorial team and exhibition line-up. The department has signalled its commitment to oversight, support, and international promotion, ensuring the pavilion represents a vibrant snapshot of South African contemporary art.

For the artists and curators involved, this represents both a challenge and an opportunity: navigating a new selection system while keeping the spotlight on the richness of South African creativity in a world-renowned forum.

{Source: IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com