High Court Shields St Helena Bay Woman From Eviction Amid Workplace Romance Fallout

Love, Work, and the Law Collide in St Helena Bay

A St Helena Bay woman has found unexpected relief in the Western Cape High Court after her life was upended by a failed workplace romance. Once an HR manager at Pioneer Fishing, Lauren Ebony Masimla was dismissed from her job and faced eviction from the company-owned home she lived in. Now, a recent court ruling has given her a temporary reprieve and a fighting chance to stay in her home while she battles her former employer in the Labour Court.

From Office Romance to Legal Battle

Masimla’s story began at Pioneer Fishing (PTY) LTD, where she started working in 2015. In 2022, she moved into a company-leased home in St Helena Bay, a benefit tied to her employment. But her personal and professional life collided when her relationship with Pieter Greeff, the company’s chief operating officer, came to an end.

After their breakup, Masimla was dismissed in June 2023 for alleged misconduct and dereliction of duty. She challenged the decision, filing a case in the Labour Court not to get her job back, but to seek a declaration of unfair dismissal and workplace harassment, along with compensation.

The Eviction That Sparked a Court Clash

Following her dismissal, Greeff served Masimla with an eviction notice in October 2023, claiming her right to stay in the property ended with her employment. The eviction process began in the Vredenburg Magistrate’s Court earlier this year under the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE Act).

The magistrate initially halted the eviction until the Labour Court ruled on Masimla’s case a decision her former employer promptly appealed.

High Court Steps In

In his ruling, Acting Judge Roy Barendse of the Western Cape High Court sided with Masimla, stating that she could not be deemed an “unlawful occupier” until the lawfulness of her dismissal was established by the Labour Court.

“Masimla’s lease can only be terminated on account of the termination of her employment if her dismissal was lawful,” said Barendse. “The appellants’ stance that because of her mere dismissal she became an unlawful occupier is opportunistic and without merit.”

The court dismissed the employer’s appeal, confirming that the original magistrate had acted correctly in halting the eviction proceedings.

What This Means for Workers

While the case is still ongoing, the ruling shines a light on how deeply workplace relationships and their breakdowns can impact employment and housing security. For many South Africans who live in company-provided accommodation, this decision reinforces that employment disputes must first be resolved before eviction can lawfully proceed.

Social media users have already rallied behind Masimla’s situation, with some describing her case as “a win for women’s dignity and labour rights,” while others see it as a warning about the blurred lines between personal relationships and professional hierarchies in the workplace.

A Pause, Not the End

For now, Masimla remains in her St Helena Bay home, awaiting the Labour Court’s final decision. Her case has become more than a private dispute it’s a reminder that the intersection of love, power, and work can have lasting legal and human consequences.

{Source:IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com