Record Pass Rate or Clever Maths? Inside the Debate Over South Africa’s 2025 Matric Results

A record to celebrate, but not without questions

South Africa’s Class of 2025 has officially made history. With an overall matric pass rate of 88%, the highest since the dawn of democracy, the national mood has largely been celebratory. Proud families, relieved learners and congratulatory messages flooded timelines across the country on Monday night as the results were released.

Basic Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube confirmed the milestone, also announcing that KwaZulu-Natal emerged as the top-performing province with a 90% pass rate.

But while many are applauding, others are squinting at the numbers, asking whether the headline figures really reflect the state of basic education in South Africa.

“Too perfect to be true?”

Among the most vocal critics is Build One South Africa (BOSA) leader Mmusi Maimane, who questioned how such strong results square with long-standing literacy challenges in schools.

He pointed to widely cited studies showing that a majority of learners struggle with reading for meaning in earlier grades, calling the 88% pass rate misleading and disconnected from classroom realities.

His comments sparked intense debate online, with some users echoing his scepticism while others accused critics of undermining learners’ hard work.

GOOD: Celebrate learners, but don’t ignore the cracks

The GOOD Party struck a more balanced tone. Secretary-general Brett Herron congratulated the Class of 2025 for reaching the finish line, acknowledging the personal and social hardships many learners faced along the way.

At the same time, he warned that headline pass rates often mask deeper structural weaknesses, particularly in under-resourced schools. Herron reserved special praise for teachers working in difficult conditions, describing them as an undervalued backbone of the education system.

DA highlights resilience and inclusion

The Democratic Alliance also welcomed the results, focusing on the resilience of learners who succeeded despite poverty, underfunded schools and systemic barriers.

DA education spokesperson Nazley Sharif said the party was encouraged by signs of progress in inclusive education, including improved outcomes for learners with special education needs. She also congratulated IEB candidates and welcomed the Department of Basic Education’s acknowledgment that serious challenges remain.

ActionSA: The “real” pass rate debate returns

ActionSA’s Lerato Ngobeni reignited a familiar argument, that the official pass rate does not reflect how many learners actually make it through the system.

She noted that only 57.7% of pupils who entered Grade 10 in 2023 completed matric in 2025, arguing that dropout rates continue to be glossed over in government celebrations.

According to Ngobeni, the focus on record-breaking percentages risks prioritising good optics over meaningful reform.

Between pride and policy

For many South Africans, both things can be true at once: the Class of 2025 deserves recognition for an extraordinary achievement and the education system still needs urgent, honest reform.

As social media reactions show, the debate is no longer about whether learners worked hard, but whether the country is being equally serious about fixing what happens long before matric exams are written.

{Source: IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com