Not All Illegal Immigrants Should Be Treated the Same, Says Opinion

Not All Illegal Immigrants Should Be Treated the Same, Says Opinion

A recent opinion article argues that current immigration enforcement practices sweep all undocumented people into the same category. Criminals and those simply seeking a better life are often treated alike in policy and public perception.

Distinguishing the “good” from the “perceived threat”

The article warns that treating everyone who lacks legal status as a criminal risks injustice. Many so-called “illegal immigrants” are hard workers supporting families, paying taxes informally or through services, and contributing quietly to society.

It argues that policy enforcement should be more precise. Authorities should target those involved in real criminal activity or abusing state resources while distinguishing them from people who pose no threat.

Fear and consequences of blanket policies

One concern raised is how broad deportation or arrest campaigns instill fear in communities. People who are undocumented but have no criminal record may avoid leaving home or accessing services out of fear of being stopped or deported.

The piece points out that this undermines trust in institutions, devalues human rights, and damages social cohesion.

A call for thoughtful reform

The writer suggests that the legal and political framework should distinguish between offenders, non-offenders, and those contributing positively to society. Not every undocumented person should face the same penalties or treatment.

Policy reform proposals include:

• Greater clarity in immigration law

• Proportional penalties based on conduct, not just status

• Protections for those who have lived unregistered but honest lives

Relevance to South Africa

Though the piece was written with other countries in mind, its arguments resonate in South Africa. The country has complex migration flows from neighbouring states and elsewhere. Hardship, opportunities, and porous borders all play roles.

South Africans often debate how to balance security and compassion. This opinion suggests that fairness demands more nuance than sweeping enforcement alone.

{Source: IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com