Culture Craze
Taylor Swift vs Charli XCX: Why ‘Actually Romantic’ Has Fans Talking
The Pop World’s Latest Puzzle: Taylor vs Charli
Every time Taylor Swift releases a song, her fans turn into detectives. With her latest album, The Life of a Showgirl, that tradition continues, and this time the mystery centres on one track, ‘Actually Romantic.’
The soft-rock ballad sounds tender at first, but listeners quickly picked up on its sharp edge. Swift sings about someone so fixated on her that it feels like love: “It’s actually romantic / No man has ever loved me like you do.” To Swifties, that line didn’t sound affectionate at all. Instead, many believe it’s aimed at fellow pop star Charli XCX.
A Friendship Gone Cold
The two singers once shared the stage; Charli opened for Swift’s Reputation World Tour and joined her during 1989 World Tour performances. But after Charli’s 2024 album Brat dropped, rumours of tension surfaced.
On that record, Charli’s track ‘Sympathy Is a Knife’ explores anxiety and comparison in the spotlight, with the lyric, “This one girl taps my insecurities.” Fans linked it to Swift, reading it as a dig at pop’s reigning superstar. Charli denied the connection, saying it reflected her own self-doubt, but the speculation stuck.
So when ‘Actually Romantic’ arrived with lines about someone “calling her names” and “writing a song about her,” fans immediately connected the dots.
A Heart Emoji That Broke the Internet
After Swift’s track went live, Charli quietly posted a studio clip with a single heart emoji. That tiny gesture was all it took for the internet to spiral. Some saw it as shade, others as a tease for a response song. Neither artist has confirmed anything, but silence only fuels the story.
how it feels liking both Taylor and Charli atm pic.twitter.com/IRvVHwj2sL
SARAH LOVES ALESSI (@sarahfangirlin) October 5, 2025
Swift’s Side of the Story
Swift later explained the song in a brief Amazon Music introduction, calling it “about realising someone has had a one-sided, adversarial relationship with you that you didn’t know about.”
To fans, that was confirmation enough. The lyrical call-and-response between ‘Sympathy Is a Knife’ and ‘Actually Romantic’ now sits alongside ‘Bad Blood’ and ‘Dear John’ in Swift’s long list of songs rumoured to hide personal drama.
Pop Culture’s Favourite Game
Pop rivalries are nothing new, but this one blends nostalgia, friendship, and internet sleuthing into a perfect storm. Whether ‘Actually Romantic’ is truly about Charli or not, it’s achieved the ultimate Swiftian feat, turning a whispered rumour into a chart-driving conversation.
And for fans, that’s half the fun.
Also read: Kanye West’s ‘Betrayal List’ Turns Internet Pain into Pure Comedy Gold
Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter, TikT
For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com
Source: IOL
Featured Image: People Magazine
