South African Government Destroys R192 Billion Annually: The High Cost of Mismanaged Debt

The South African government is under fire for its financial mismanagement, with economist Dawie Roodt revealing that it destroys approximately R192 billion annually by borrowing long-term to fund short-term expenses. This alarming revelation came during a presentation on the 2025 Budget delivered by Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana, highlighting the dire state of the country’s finances.

The Cost of Mismanaged Debt

Roodt, chief economist at Efficient Group, explained that the government’s practice of borrowing long-term to cover short-term expenditures is akin to destroying capital. “The South African government destroys approximately R200 billion annually by borrowing long-term and spending it on short-term items,” he said. This approach creates a mismatch in the time horizon of liabilities, leading to financial strain as debt accumulates interest and becomes increasingly difficult to service.

In his 2025 budget speech, Godongwana acknowledged the severity of the situation, stating that government debt is expected to reach 76.2% of South Africa’s gross domestic product (GDP) this financial year. Debt-servicing costs alone amounted to R389.6 billion over the last financial year, consuming 22 cents of every rand raised in revenue. “It is more than what we spend on health, the police, and basic education,” Godongwana told Parliament.

Rising Debt-Servicing Costs

The outlook for the next financial year is equally grim, with debt-servicing costs projected to increase by 9% to R424.9 billion. This makes interest payments one of the fastest-growing items in the 2025 Budget. Roodt emphasized that the government’s debt obligations extend beyond what is reported, including implicit and explicit guarantees to state-owned enterprises (SOEs).

“There are implicit and explicit debts that Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana must include in his outstanding debt estimates. He does not do that,” Roodt said. South Africa has R770 billion in guarantees to SOEs, which are not reflected in the official debt levels shared by Godongwana.

The Challenge of Additional Borrowing

Godongwana admitted that taking on additional debt to meet spending pressures is not feasible. “The amount is simply too large. The cost of borrowing would be unaffordable,” he said. South Africa’s sub-investment credit rating further complicates the issue, making borrowing costlier and increasing the risk of further downgrades.

To address these challenges, the government is exploring strong fiscal policy anchors to prevent a recurrence of high spending, high deficits, and high debt. “At present, a primary budget surplus sufficient to stabilize debt has been adopted as the anchor,” Godongwana explained. However, he noted that the obligation to keep public debt stable is not explicitly defined in South Africa’s legal and regulatory framework.

A History of Budget Deficits

South Africa’s budget deficits have been a recurring issue over the past 15 years. The chart below illustrates the government’s consistent overspending, which has contributed to the current debt crisis. Godongwana expects the consolidated budget deficit to narrow from 5% of GDP in 2024/25 to 3.5% of GDP in 2027/28, but achieving this will require significant fiscal discipline.

The Broader Impact

The mismanagement of government debt has far-reaching consequences for South Africa’s economy. High debt-servicing costs divert resources away from critical social needs, such as healthcare, education, and policing. This, in turn, exacerbates inequality and hampers economic growth.

Roodt’s analysis underscores the urgent need for reform. Without addressing the root causes of financial mismanagement, South Africa risks falling into a deeper debt trap, with severe implications for future generations.

The South African government’s mismanagement of debt is destroying R192 billion annually, according to economist Dawie Roodt. As debt-servicing costs continue to rise, the country faces mounting financial strain, diverting resources from essential services and hindering economic growth. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana’s 2025 Budget highlights the need for fiscal discipline and structural reforms to stabilize public debt. However, without explicit legal and regulatory frameworks to enforce these measures, the path to recovery remains uncertain.

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com