Retailers in South Africa: Who is Thriving and Who is Struggling Amid Economic Pressures?

In South Africa’s retail landscape, performance has been mixed, with economic pressures shaping how various brands and sectors fare. While retailers initially benefited from the post-election momentum and hopes for economic recovery, these hopes have faded as limited economic reforms and high taxes hinder the anticipated growth.

The Impact of the Two-Pot Retirement System

The two-pot retirement system was expected to inject billions into the hands of consumers, with estimates putting it at around R43 billion, as calculated by the South African Revenue Service (SARS). However, the money didn’t have the anticipated impact on discretionary spending. Consumers used the funds for more immediate needs such as school fees and paying down debt, rather than splurging on non-essential purchases.

This underscores the real issue: South Africa’s sluggish economy. The fourth-quarter GDP growth was a modest 0.6%, largely driven by a rebound in agriculture from a low base. This resulted in no real per capita improvement, and debt-to-GDP continues to rise, signaling further economic strain.

Retailers’ Performance: Who’s Struggling, Who’s Holding Up?

Lower-middle-income retailers, like PEP and Mr Price, are performing better than their middle-to-upper-income counterparts. These brands are benefiting from consumers’ efforts to make their money stretch further amid tough times.

• Woolworths and Truworths are facing more significant pressure due to high interest rates, which continue to strain the high-income consumer.
• Food retail, however, is seeing better performance, with Woolworths Food maintaining strong global top-line growth, alongside Shoprite’s Checkers expanding significantly. Checkers has successfully captured market share from Pick n Pay and Spar, becoming a leader in convenience-focused retail.

On the other hand, Spar is struggling, with their Sixty60 delivery service failing to keep pace with Checkers’ dominant presence.

Economic Pressures and Consumer Spending Trends

The current economic environment suggests that South Africans are still getting poorer, and without structural reforms, challenges will continue. While falling food and fuel prices have given lower-income consumers some relief, it has done little to spark a major increase in discretionary spending. The two-pot retirement system’s impact is also limited, as people direct the funds towards basic living costs rather than spending on non-essentials.

Naspers and Prosus: Riding the Tencent Wave

Outside of retail, Naspers and Prosus remain reliant on Tencent, their largest asset, for financial performance. Tencent continues to drive the performance of Naspers and Prosus, despite some early concerns over the US-China relationship.

While Tencent stocks suffered a sell-off after being placed on the US Department of Defence’s restricted list, the market has rallied on the improvement in China-US relations, especially after China’s President Xi Jinping met with top CEOs from Chinese tech giants like Tencent and Alibaba.

Additionally, Tencent’s advancements in AI, through the integration of Deepseek and the YUANBAO app, have added to the positive momentum, driving growth and recovery for Naspers and Prosus.

A Mixed Picture for South African Retailers

As South Africa’s retail sector navigates economic pressures, the picture remains mixed. PEP and Mr Price appear better positioned for growth, while Woolworths and Truworths face increasing pressure, especially with the high-income consumer under strain. The key to surviving these challenges will be consistency in project rollouts, consumer spending shifts, and better government engagement on broader economic reform.

As for Naspers and Prosus, the rebound in Tencent’s stock has helped stabilize their financial performance, but the retail sector’s recovery may take longer, with economic reforms necessary to boost consumer confidence and spending power in South Africa.

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com