South Africa’s Expropriation Bill Ignites Diplomatic Tensions with Trump’s US

South Africa’s new Expropriation Bill, signed into law in December 2024, has ignited a diplomatic firestorm with the United States. President Donald Trump’s administration has criticized the legislation, viewing it as a threat to property rights and a direct challenge to white Afrikaners. In response, the US has cut $440 million (R8 billion) in aid, escalating tensions between the two nations.

The US Reaction: A Flex of Muscle?

South Africans perceive the US response as an attempt to assert dominance on the global stage. Trump’s executive order accused South Africa of a “shocking disregard” for citizens’ rights, claiming the bill enables land seizures without compensation. While the legislation does allow for “nil compensation” in specific cases, such as when land is unused, abandoned, or poses a public hazard, South Africa insists this is not a blanket policy.

President Cyril Ramaphosa has defended the bill as a “constitutionally mandated” tool to address historical land inequities, not a populist land grab. The bill’s text supports this, permitting zero compensation under certain conditions while allowing owners to seek “just and equitable” payment through negotiation or the courts.

A Far Cry from Zimbabwe’s Land Reforms

South Africa’s approach is markedly different from Zimbabwe’s chaotic land grabs in 2000, which led to economic collapse. The Expropriation Bill is designed to balance land reform with legal safeguards, ensuring that land redistribution is conducted within the framework of the law.

Selective Outrage from the US

Critics argue that the US’s outrage is selective. The Trump administration has amplified the rhetoric of Julius Malema, leader of the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), who supports expropriation, as if he represents the South African government. However, the African National Congress (ANC), now in a coalition with the Democratic Alliance (DA), governs the country. The DA is even challenging the bill in court, arguing it is unconstitutional.

Why the US Fixation?

The US’s strong reaction may be linked to South Africa’s case against Israel at the International Court of Justice or its membership in BRICS, which signals Pretoria’s willingness to engage with both Western and Eastern powers. Trump’s aid cut appears to be a punitive measure disguised as a principled stand.

Rooted in History

South Africa’s land reform efforts are deeply rooted in its history. A 2017 audit revealed that 72% of farmland was owned by white South Africans, who make up just 8% of the population, while Black South Africans, comprising 80% of the population, held only 4%. The Expropriation Bill operationalizes Section 25 of the Constitution, which already allows expropriation for public interest, including land reform.

Challenges and Criticisms

Legal experts like Ayanda Khumalo of Webber Wentzel warn that the bill may not achieve its goals and could bog down reform in bureaucratic red tape. The DA’s opposition and legal challenges highlight the contentious nature of the legislation. However, these disputes are a sign of a healthy democracy, not a collapse.

The Global Dimension

The diplomatic clash is less about South Africa and more about who gets to judge. The African Union, shaped by colonial legacies, is unlikely to welcome external interference. As the G20 chair this year, South Africa is working to manage the fallout, dispatching envoys to Washington, Beijing, and other capitals to smooth relations and secure investment.

Will the Expropriation Bill solve South Africa’s land issues? Unlikely—it’s a step, not a cure. Will the US’s criticism derail it? Also unlikely. The real story is how South Africa navigates its complex history while striving for a more equitable future—a challenge shared by many nations across Africa.

As South Africa charts its course, the world watches, reminding us that the path to justice and reform is rarely straightforward.

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com