Arithmetic Delusion”: Trump’s 30% Tariffs on South Africa Begin Amid Global Backlash

As of today, April 9, 2025, South African exports to the United States are now subject to a 30% tariff, following a controversial decision by President Donald Trump to impose sweeping duties on more than 100 countries. South Africa was labeled one of the “worst offenders” and singled out in Trump’s rhetoric as a country that has been “ripping off” the American taxpayer.

False Claims Meet Official Data

Trump claimed Pretoria imposes 60% tariffs on US imports — a statement that has been thoroughly debunked by his own administration. Just days before the announcement, the 2025 National Trade Estimate Report on Foreign Trade Barriers, released by the Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR), showed that South Africa’s average tariff rate is only 7.6%.

Most of South Africa’s tariff lines — 93.8%, to be exact — are bound under World Trade Organization (WTO) rules, offering predictability and transparency in its trade policy. The few 60%+ tariffs apply only to niche agricultural products like dairy and sugar, which rarely impact US exports to South Africa.

Trump’s “Reciprocal Trade Formula”

So why the 30% tariff?

According to Trump, the answer lies in his “reciprocal trade formula.” Under this approach, if a country has a trade surplus with the US, it is seen as taking unfair advantage. The surplus is then used to calculate what Trump views as a justified tariff.

For South Africa, the trade surplus — driven largely by exports of cars, platinum, and citrus — was twisted into a justification for the 30% tariff. Economists have widely panned this method, calling it “arithmetic delusion” and accusing Trump of manipulating data to support a political narrative.

Risking Agoa and Global Diplomacy

The move has sparked concern not only in Pretoria but across the globe. Analysts warn that the tariff decision violates the spirit of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa), which grants South Africa and other African nations preferential access to US markets in exchange for promoting development and democratic reforms.

South Africa’s Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Parks Tau, responded firmly:

“We now have to look amongst ourselves… how we’re going to respond to these issues.”

A Global Trade Earthquake

Trump’s tariff decision goes far beyond South Africa. A 10% baseline tariff on countries like Australia, Britain, Egypt, and Saudi Arabia came into force on Saturday. A second wave, with rates from 11% to 50%, starts today.

• European Union goods now face a 20% duty

• China’s exports will be hit with a shocking 84% increase, raising overall US tariffs on Chinese goods to 104%

The implications are massive. Markets are jittery. Trade partners are threatening retaliation. And global economists are warning of long-term damage to trade systems and supply chains.

Politics Over Policy?

Critics say Trump’s trade war is being driven more by political theater than sound economics. By ignoring official trade data and creating new “formulas” to justify protectionism, the Trump administration may be undermining decades of multilateral trade agreements and global cooperation.

For South African exporters, today marks the beginning of a costly chapter — one rooted more in arithmetic fantasy than trade reality.

{Source IOL}

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com