Business
Pick n Pay’s Self-Service Checkout Tills: A Quiet Evolution Amid Challenges

In 2016, Pick n Pay introduced self-service checkout tills at its Ottery store in Cape Town, aiming to help customers who were in a rush and looking for a quicker, more convenient shopping experience. This innovation, similar to what we see in advanced economies like the UK, was designed to make shopping faster and more efficient, especially for customers buying just a few items.
While self-service checkout technology has become commonplace in places like Tesco and Marks & Spencer, Pick n Pay’s South African implementation faced several hurdles that have led to questions about its long-term viability.
Union Resistance and Public Concerns
One of the significant challenges that Pick n Pay faced in its rollout of self-service checkouts came from the trade union Cosatu, which vehemently opposed the technology. Cosatu argued that self-service checkouts could result in job losses for South African workers, causing widespread concern among employees. The union’s opposition led to threats of boycotts, and there was no follow-up from the retailer for years after its initial tests.
The backlash came at a time when Pick n Pay had already made significant moves to improve efficiency and productivity within its workforce. The company had announced the removal of approximately 10% of its roles due to technological advancements, a move that further fueled resistance to self-service technology.
Security Concerns and Crime Rates
Another obstacle in South Africa’s adoption of self-checkout tills is the country’s high crime and shoplifting rates. Retailers like Pick n Pay face unique challenges in balancing technology and security. The risk of theft at self-checkout stations is a valid concern, as customers may exploit these systems to bypass security measures and steal items.
The success of self-checkout systems in countries like the UK has not translated well to South Africa, where crime is a significant issue. Despite these challenges, no major South African retailer has fully embraced the self-service checkout model in the way global companies have.
A Global Perspective: Are Self-Checkouts Still the Future?
Internationally, the effectiveness of self-service checkout technology is under scrutiny. Retailers like Target and Walmart in the United States have begun to rethink their reliance on self-checkout machines. Walmart even removed some machines in response to theft concerns, while UK-based supermarket chain Booths scaled back its use of self-checkout kiosks after customers complained about slow service and technical issues.
Even Dollar General, a rapidly growing U.S. retailer, has decided to scale back its self-checkout strategy. CEO Todd Vasos commented that the company had relied too heavily on self-checkouts and planned to use them as a secondary checkout option rather than the primary one.
Pick n Pay’s Quiet Retreat
Despite initial enthusiasm, Pick n Pay has remained silent on the status of its self-service checkout initiative. Whether the project was abandoned due to union pressure, security challenges, or global retail trends, the retailer has refrained from discussing the issue publicly. With the growing criticism of self-checkout systems worldwide and the specific challenges of the South African market, Pick n Pay may have been wise to put a pause on this innovation for the time being.
The Future of Retail Technology in South Africa
The story of Pick n Pay’s self-service tills serves as a cautionary tale for South African retailers. While the desire for innovation is strong, the country’s unique challenges—ranging from labor relations to security issues—must be considered before adopting new technologies. Retailers will need to carefully evaluate whether the benefits of such technology outweigh the costs and risks involved.
Ultimately, as technology continues to evolve, South Africa’s retailers will have to balance innovation with the realities of the local market. Whether or not self-service checkouts will become the norm in South Africa remains to be seen, but for now, it seems the journey of this retail technology is on pause.
Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram
For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com