Business
South Africa’s Medical Aid Battle: BHF Takes Legal Action to Push for Affordable Health Plans

The ongoing battle for affordable healthcare in South Africa has taken a new turn, as the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF) has once again headed to the courts. The BHF, a non-profit representing over 40 medical schemes, is fighting to compel the Council for Medical Schemes (CMS) to approve Low-Cost Benefit Options (LCBOs). These plans, offering essential primary healthcare services at significantly lower costs, are seen as a critical solution for millions of South Africans in need of affordable healthcare.
The Long Wait for Affordable Healthcare Solutions
The fight for LCBOs has been ongoing for over a decade. The CMS initially passed a resolution in 2015 to create a framework for these low-cost healthcare plans but has failed to implement the policy. The delay has been attributed to concerns over the plans’ comprehensiveness, particularly their failure to cover national health priorities like HIV and other prevalent diseases. Despite this, the BHF has pushed for the adoption of LCBOs, which it argues could provide immediate, affordable healthcare for over 10 million South Africans.
Why the CMS is Holding Back on LCBOs
The CMS and the National Department of Health have cited the government’s National Health Insurance (NHI) scheme as a reason for the delay. The NHI is set to gradually replace private healthcare schemes, and the government is reluctant to approve low-cost private medical aid plans that might undermine the future of the NHI. However, critics argue that the NHI is still years, if not decades, away from full implementation, leaving millions of South Africans without affordable healthcare in the meantime.
In response to these delays, the BHF took the CMS to court in 2022, demanding the immediate approval of LCBOs. The court action came after the CMS continued to stall on implementing guidelines for the plans, citing the government’s focus on the NHI. As a result, the BHF is now asking the court to intervene and force the CMS to allow medical schemes to offer LCBOs and provide affordable care for those who cannot afford more comprehensive medical aid options.
The Growing Pressure on the CMS and Health Department
The BHF’s legal push highlights a critical issue in South Africa’s healthcare system: the need for immediate solutions for the country’s low-income population. With the NHI still years away from being fully implemented, the BHF argues that LCBOs could offer a viable solution to provide affordable primary healthcare to millions today.
The NHI Act, signed into law in 2024, remains a point of contention. Critics, including the BHF, argue that the Act could worsen the situation by eliminating private medical schemes altogether, which would leave millions of South Africans without affordable care. The Act’s implementation timeline is uncertain, with experts predicting it could take decades to fully roll out. Meanwhile, the BHF argues that LCBOs could immediately address healthcare gaps by providing affordable plans that would help low-income earners access essential healthcare services without relying on state-funded solutions.
The Stakes for South Africans and Their Health
As the court date approaches on 28 January 2025, the BHF is determined to push for immediate action. The stakes are high, as the outcome of this legal battle could determine the future of affordable healthcare for millions of South Africans. According to the BHF, the CMS has the power to approve LCBOs today, but it is choosing to delay, citing the future of the NHI as its primary reason.
For many South Africans, the situation is dire. The BHF’s statement highlights that healthcare is a current need, not something to be postponed indefinitely. Affordable healthcare options, such as LCBOs, are crucial in ensuring that those who cannot afford traditional medical aid plans still have access to primary healthcare services.
The BHF’s Call for Action and Collaboration
The BHF is clear in its message: it is ready to work with the government to find a solution, but that solution must be immediate and practical. LCBOs, it argues, offer a realistic pathway to making healthcare affordable for South Africans today. While the NHI remains a long-term goal, the BHF believes that collaboration between the private and public sectors is necessary to bridge the gap and achieve universal healthcare coverage in South Africa.
The next chapter in South Africa’s healthcare debate is about to unfold in the courts, and the BHF is determined to ensure that affordable healthcare is a reality for millions of South Africans now, not years from now.
A Call for Immediate Healthcare Reform
The BHF’s court action is a critical step toward ensuring affordable healthcare for all South Africans. While the National Health Insurance (NHI) scheme is being positioned as a future solution, the country cannot afford to wait decades for it to materialize. LCBOs, with their potential to offer essential primary healthcare at affordable rates, could provide an immediate solution to the pressing needs of South Africans who are being left behind by the current system.
As the legal battle continues, the BHF is calling on the government to prioritize healthcare solutions that can be implemented immediately, rather than waiting for the uncertain future of the NHI.
Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram
For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com